Fabricators, This is an opportunity to influence the acceptability of your product! The IPC Standards Development Committee is working on the next revision to IPC-A-600 (Acceptability of Printed Boards) which is a visual reference companion to IPC-6012. One of the items we are currently discussing is the acceptability of haloing along the board edge. Here is a link to where we stand now: http://frontdoor.biz/PCBportal/IPC-A-600H213.jpg The problem is, if the designer violates the recommendation in the current IPC-2221 design guideline and puts traces or planes too close to the board outline, with the current wording of "whichever is less" your boards can be considered rejectable with even a very small amount of haloing. Even intentional features like edge fingers can make your boards rejectable. We aren't sure if we should reword this (and if so, how?) So the ball is in your court (because unless there is a logical consensus we probably won't change it). I'll compile and submit any responses to the next committee meeting. Jack (aka "the new guy")